Following the recent LGBT and the Church Unbelievable? show, author Mark Roques explores how Greek philosophy helps illuminate our understanding of sex
The recent Unbelievable? Live show on sexuality, gender and identity was a very good evening. Justin Brierley interviewed Andrew Bunt and Charlie Bell on one of the burning issues of the day. Is a practising, gay lifestyle compatible with biblical teaching?
I thought the tone and the content were excellent. Justin was gracious, as always, and both Andrew and Charlie debated in a warm and civil manner. It was wonderful to behold.
I wanted to raise some questions but I decided it would take too long to explain my interest in Epicurus (341-270 BC) and Aristippus (435-356 BC). Am I a sad loser? Probably.
I am not talking here about ancient Greek footballers but influential Greek philosophers. Today we are witnessing a revival of the Epicurean way of life and it illuminates all discussions about sex and how we understand sexuality. Scholars like NT Wright and Catherine Wilson are helping us to understand the pervasive Epicurean worldview.
Here is my brief, pithy outline of these two influential boffins: Epicurus and Aristippus. Understanding their worldviews can help us think about sex.
While Epicureanism today is often understood to refer to a person’s refined appreciation of ‘posh nosh’ and sophisticated, fine wines, we need to dig deeper.
Epicurus rejected the platonic belief in immortal souls and invisible, spiritual realities. Epicurus taught that the basic constituents of the world are atoms, uncuttable bits of matter, flying through empty space and he attempted to explain all natural phenomena in atomic terms. He was inspired by Democritus (460-370 BC), who was one of the first materialist thinkers to be born. It is worth noting that Plato wanted to burn all of Democritus’ books. Friends they were not.
It was this theory of reality (atomistic materialism) that inspired Epicurus’ ethical teaching. For Epicurus the worst pain is fear. Fear of death and hell, he believed, causes a huge amount of anxiety and misery in the lives of Greek citizens who feared the gods e.g. Zeus. So he writes: “Nothing to fear in death; pleasure can be attained; pain can be endured.”
Epicurus taught his disciples that when we stop fearing death, we must turn to enjoy a life of happiness. Only physical stuff is real and this means that we must focus upon enjoying our lives in the here and now. For Epicurus, this means a life of moderation and self-control.
Epicureans seek tranquillity (ataraxia) and this will lead to the blessed life. We chat amiably in delightful gardens, enjoying clever banter, philosophical musings and the occasional glass of sherry. Epicureans were ‘secular’ people who lived as if there was no God, soul or judgement day. They did believe in gods but these gods had no interest in human affairs. Epicureans ignored God and the gods. Sound familiar?
Get access to exclusive bonus content & updates: register & sign up to the Premier Unbelievable? newsletter!
Notice that this contrasts strongly with Aristippus who urged his disciples to engage in full-on, unrestrained, ‘blow out’ hedonism. Aristippus was an evangelist for the ‘wine, women and song’ way of life. It is foolish to delay any cravings for pleasure, taught Aristippus. So live wildly and in the moment.
The book Hellraisers by Robert Sellers tells the outrageous stories of Richard Burton, Peter O’Toole, Richard Harris and Oliver Reed. These men were followers of Aristippus rather than Epicurus. Their sexual shenanigans were rampant and they consumed vast quantities of wine and other alcoholic beverages. In 1974, Reed and 36 rugby players went through 60 gallons of beer, 32 bottles of scotch, 17 bottles of gin, four crates of wine and a solitary bottle of Babycham!
Unapologetic #18 Mary Jo Sharp: How to talk with young people about love, porn and sex
Unbelievable? God, Gay Christians and the Church - Brandan Robertson and David Bennett
Unbelievable? Sean McDowell live Q&A on sexuality, transgender and culture war questions
Unbelievable? Jackie Hill Perry Q&A: Same sex attraction, transgender, racism and more
Unbelievable? How should the church treat LGBT people? Preston Sprinkle & Brandan Robertson
The profound materialism of both Epicurus and Aristippus gives rise to social contract theories (e.g. Locke), in which governments arise through the actions of lonely, naked, solitary individuals. At the end of the day there are only individual, physical things and persons. These individuals crave material sensuality and satisfaction because only physical stuff is real.
Today, many western people follow Epicurus and Aristippus without knowing why. For some, their tranquillity is sacred. For others, their carnal pleasures are sacred. We could call these people unreflective materialists. Materialism is a broad Church embracing both sophisticated aesthetes and pub brawlers.
How does this illuminate our discussions about sex?
Andrew Bunt pointed out that western culture is obsessed with sex and satisfying our sexual desires is perfectly normal. He explained that Jesus lived an abundant life while remaining chaste. Understanding the revival of Epicureanism can help us to dig deeper into this debate about sexuality and the Christian faith. Understanding the Epicurean worldview is vital for both mission and discipleship.
This article was originally published on the Thinking Faith Network website.
Mark Roques taught Philosophy and Religious Education at Prior Park College, Bath, for many years. As Director of RealityBites he has developed a rich range of resources for youth workers and teachers. He has spoken at conferences in the UK, Holland, South Korea, Spain, Australia and New Zealand. Mark is a lively storyteller and the author of four books, including The Spy, the Rat and the Bed of Nails: Creative Ways of Talking about Christian Faith. His work is focused on storytelling and how this can help us to communicate the Christian faith. He has written many articles for the Baptist Times, RE Today, Youthscape, Direction magazine and the Christian Teachers Journal.