Jordan Peterson’s refusal to clarify his religious beliefs is drawing scrutiny from both his secular and Christian followers, raising questions about whether his signature ambiguity now undermines his credibility. As calls for authenticity grow louder, is Peterson’s legacy as a bold thinker at risk if he continues to sidestep the question of faith?
Read more:
Is Jordan Peterson drawing closer to the Christian faith?
What does NT Wright think of Jordan Peterson?
How Jordan Peterson led me to Jesus
The rockstar philosopher and intellectual, Jordan Peterson, may be seeing his popularity begin to wane. For years, he represented a sure-footed intellectual step for those exploring what it meant to live an effective human life. But his recent performance on the Jubilee debate has many questioning whether Peterson can still be relied on to deliver the unfiltered truth upon which his reputation was built.
For those unfamiliar with the exchange, Peterson was asked point-blank whether he was a Christian. His response: “I could be either of them, but I don’t have to tell you.” The conversation quickly became heated, and the clip has since gone viral.
Peterson’s ambiguity on his religious beliefs isn’t new. It has, in many ways, allowed him to unite a rare mix of audiences: champions of free speech and intellectual enquiry on one side, and traditional Christian audiences on the other. That ability to bridge such divergent groups has been his defining strength.
In today’s intellectual marketplace, authenticity is a non-negotiable quality. Peterson’s refusal to address his core beliefs directly risks turning him from a respected voice into an evasive figure whose intellectual depth is questioned. And this recent episode highlights the growing cost of his refusal to take a stand. You can’t please all the people all the time - and Peterson is starting to encounter that reality a decade into his fame.
For years, he has pontificated on what it means to live a good life. His 12 Rules for Life and We Who Wrestle With God have been international bestsellers. Yet both sides of his audience now want an answer: from what source does Peterson ultimately derive his morality? His oft-quoted line, “I choose to live as if God exists,” once felt profound. Today, it looks like the intellectual peak of a philosopher who promised so much yet ultimately committed to nothing.
As any seasoned sales and marketing professional will tell you, authenticity is non-negotiable. The moment you are perceived as evasive or inauthentic, people switch off. Peterson risks being consigned to the intellectual scrapheap - not because he lacks brilliance, but because he is bold in some areas and evasive in the one question that matters most.
There comes a point when every thinker must speak plainly. For someone as well-read and influential as Jordan Peterson, the season for ambiguity is over. Now is the moment to answer, without evasion or clever phrasing: does he trust in Christ, or not?
Drew Cordell is a business consultant who has worked alongside some of the world’s most successful businesses and their leaders in an extensive corporate career in both London and Australia. His new book, Honest Christianity: Why People Choose to Believe, is available on Amazon and all good bookstores.
