Jesus was a Jew. Christianity owes its birth to Judaism. But did Jesus represent the fulfilment of Jewish Messianic hopes and prophecy?

Jonathan Romain is Rabbi of a Reform Synagogue in Maidenhead and was recently named as one of the most influential Jews in the UK. He believes that whatever Jesus was, he was not the Messiah promised in the Old Testament.

Stephen Pacht is a Messianic Jew. He believes Jesus is the Messiah the Jews were promised, but has not been recognised yet by many fellow Jews.


Get the MP3

For Rabbi Jonathan Romain 

For Stephen Pacht 

For more Christian/non-Christian debate visit 

Get the MP3 Podcast or subscribe via iTunes

Join the conversation on Facebook and Twitter

If you enjoyed this programme you may also enjoy

Unbelievable? 24 May 2008 Jesus & Jewishness: are they compatible? Rabbi Shmuley Boteach & Michael Brown debate