Joe Rigney calls empathy a sin. Alastair Roberts says not so fast. Who’s right?
Today, we explore a question at the heart of pastoral care, public witness, and Christian leadership: Is empathy a virtue to be cultivated or a vice to be resisted?
Professor Joe Rigney and Dr Alastair Roberts joined Andy Kind. Joe is the author of The Sin of Empathy, a provocative work that argues that when empathy becomes “untethered” from truth, it ceases to be a virtue and can even become sinful. Alastair, a fellow theologian, has written a substantial critique, arguing that Joe’s language has muddied important distinctions and potentially misrepresents a vital Christian posture. This conversation is not about labels, but substance - and we’ll explore everything from scriptural foundations to gender roles, pastoral ethics, and theological nuance. Can caring too much ever become morally wrong?
If you are already a Member or have an account with another Premier website, you can SIGN IN now.
Be equipped to confidently defend your Faith, tackle untruths and demonstrate that the Gospel is good news for everyone.
Membership includes unlimited access to the website, a weekly newsletter, bonus content and much more.
To continue reading REGISTER FOR FREE MEMBERSHIP